Skip to main content

"Right Reason" and the Princeton Mind

Paul Kjoss Helseth, professor of Christian Thought at Northwestern College in St. Paul has just written an insightful, combative, and well researched work about the Old Princetonian theologians and the modern assumption about their theology. The modern thesis concerning these men (Archibald Alexander, Charles Hodge, B.B. Wafield, J. Gresham Machen) is that their theology is basically warmed over rationalism taken from the Scottish Common Sense philosophy movement of the 19th century. Helseth argues in ch. 1 that this interpretation denies the moral nature of the Princetonian thought and also fails to see their religious epistemology with respect to the soul's affective and rational components (5).

Helseth goes on to provide the moral context in which the Princeton theologians wrote about concerning the relationship between spiritual knowledge and speculative knowledge and also the the use of "right reason." "Right reason" for Archibald Alexander "is the work of the Spirit that not only brings the mind into a state in which it can perceive the Word of God.." (36). It is impossible to accuse Alexander and the Princeton theologians of mere radical rationality because of their view of the moral nature of saving faith.

My favorite part of the book deals with the aspect of J. Gresham Machen's writing focusing on the Christians' relationship to the modern culture. Helseth points out that Machen taught that believing scholars should pursue the assimilation of modern learning to Christian truth (111). Why? Because saving faith is based upon the rational appropriation of objective evidence overagainst the the religious experience of modern man (112). Secondly, Machen taught that the modern mind is hostile to "the gospel of Jesus" because their thinking is dominated by ideas that are both anti-supernatural and opposed to the faith (113). Instead, proper assimilation takes place when the gospel of Jesus Christ comes to bear upon every facet of society, every place man is called to work, worship, and gather. The beauty of this analysis of Helseth on Machen is that he is directly connected to the Amsterdam theology of Abraham Kuyper. Rather than be opposed to the Kuyperian spirit of having the gospel being transformative in every "sphere" of life, Machen brought the object of saving faith to bear upon every activity, including academic argument.

The great thing about this book is that it is so well researched that reading the footnotes provide a course in early Princeton theology. Helseth near the end of the book goes onto state how the post-conservative movement in theology has imbibed the same spirit towards our Princeton forebears. They make stinging remarks about the propositional rationality of the Princeton theologians without ever taking the time to read them well. Helseth reminds his readers that to make blanket remarks without taking the time to do proper research into primary source material is detrimental to their positions. Overall, this book was a breath of fresh air for someone who was somewhat familiar with Warfield, Hodge, Alexander, and Machen. This book has defintely given me a push to read more about them and their theology. Thanks to P & R for providing a review copy.


Popular posts from this blog

My Favorite Color is Blue. Sometimes.: A Journey Through Loss with Art and Color

My Favorite Color is Blue. Sometimes by Roger Hutchison

Taking a look at the digital copy of this book allowed me to look at the striking art inside the book, and its connection to the words of the page that were focusing on loss.  Looking at the physical copy of the book even brings to life more the staggering similarity that the words and pain have together on the page.  The focus here is how certain colors express the sentiments of those who have lost a loved one.  I did not think that I would relate too well to this book until two days ago, as we lost our little boy, who was only 17 weeks old.  The pain is palpable and yet the pages of this book give me good reason to think of my son with a sense of pride and hope.

Roger writes, "You are a shooting star. Your light trails across the heavens.  I blinked and you were gone."  We were full of anticipation at the first and second ultrasounds, and there was the picture of our little boy Jackson, his developing face and little …

The Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South

Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose by Flannery O’Connor
A profound simplicity of thought, a penetrating vision of what it means to be human, Flannery O’Connor embodies the spirit of bringing fictional stories to life.  Others might call her fiction ‘grotesque’ in a rather unflattering manner, but O’Connor was not content to live up to their criticisms.  In this short book of collected essay and lectures, Mystery and Manners, editors and friends of Flannery, Robert and Sally Fitzgerald have given us a glimpse into the vision of her faith, style and life as a writer.   A lifelong Catholic, Flannery O’Connor sought to wed together the moral integrity of her faith with the character of her craft in writing.  Specifically, fiction for her was an exploration in imitation.
In a rather illuminating statement in the chapter entitled, “A Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South, “ O’Connor writes,
“I am specifically concerned with fiction because that is what I write.  There is a certain em…