Skip to main content

Luther and His Troubled Conscience


“Since Brother Martin was so troubled by his sin and unworthiness, Staupitz first advised that he seek forgiveness in the sacrament of penance.  Going to confession helped Luther, but only to a point.  Luther began to confess his sins frequently, often on a daily basis, and sometimes in great detail.  He analyzed every sin, every motive, every circumstance, scrupulously.  His fellow priests grew tired of hearing his obsessive confessions.  Some began to avoid him on purpose.  Johann van Staupitz, a very patient man, exploded one day: “Look here”, he said to Luther, “if you expect Christ to forgive you, come in with something to forgive – patricide, blasphemy, adultery – instead of all these small faults.”  But this advice was useless to Luther.  His anxiety was not over the magnitude of his sins, or their sheer number, but over whether they had been correctly confessed.  What about unrecognized sins?  Or forgotten sins?  What about his motives, especially?  After all, a good act committed for the wrong motive could count as a sin – for example, performing and act of charity out of vainglory.  Motives were hard to discern correctly.  And confession was no cure for Brother Martin.”

Carlos Eire, Reformations: The Early Modern World, 1450-1650, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2016. 142.

We chide Luther for his obsessive character in wanting to name and deplore every little sin, both known and unknown during his time at the Augustinian monastery.  Motives are most difficult to discern because they lie in the dormant machinations of our minds, often not even seeing the light of day unless a superior demands a reason.  Yet, for Luther, his view of God and his judgment, and his own anxiety ridden heart, one tiny speck of sin was enough to throw him out of the presence and plan of God.  He had to be utterly sure that his confession of sin(s) cornered every aspect of his sin, both in its breaking God’s law but also keeping him in line with the righteous judge.  Looking back, it is easy to find this kind of confession amusing, putting him in the camp of someone who has a psychological disorder (OCD) and seeing him as verging on crazy.  Yet, is that all we can gain from studying this man who helped reform the world?

Luther’s troubled conscience built inside of him a spirit of despair.  These bouts of despair, Anfechtung (Eire states that there is no English equivalent) were “an affliction inseparable from temptation,…a downward spiral leading to hell itself, which made Luther think that God had abandoned him forever and that God’s promises were false.” (141)   Tormenting rushes of doubt, affliction, and devilish accusations, Luther was weighed down with grief and pain.  Eire continues, “Images of Christ terrified him, and especially those that depicted the Final Judgment…Unable to withstand the thought of Christ as judge, rather than as redeemer, Luther could find no solace in the Mass, or in the iconography that surrounded him.” (141). Judgment meant expulsion from the promises of God but also the structure that God had built in the church.  There was no escaping from God’s utter displeasure of sin and of his existence for Luther, he could not confess enough to meet God’s standard. 

How does a German monk go from fits of despair and affliction to the beauty of God in understanding his righteousness?  Too quickly we want to give the answer to the Scriptures, for they were instrumental in changing Luther’s mind of the righteousness of God (Romans 1:17-18).  But these were not the first steps toward the God of all grace.  No, often a friend leads another friend to the well of mercy.  It is the same for Luther.  Eire quotes Martin’s own words, “I got nothing from Erasmus.  Everything I have came from Staupitz.” (142)  Johann van Staupitz was Luther’s spiritual adviser, both spiritually and in his work duties.  He was a patient man, with enough long suffering to endure the many confessions of Brother Martin.  Yet, he knew that Brother Martin’s despair could only be drawn out by specific tasks.  Eire notes, “…so he ordered him to obtain a doctorate in biblical studies.  Luther complained that he was much too fragile and unstable for such work, but Staupitz would not back down and Luther had no choice but to fulfill his vow of obedience.” (142-143)  Without the push of Staupitz, would Luther had discovered justification by faith or any of the other doctrines that we hold so close because of the Reformation?  We do not know the answer to the that question, but we do know that the prodding of Staupitz paved the way for Luther to open up the Scriptures, and this was a turning point for the Reformation.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Rise of the Modern Self by Carl Trueman

  The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self by Carl Trueman Navigating the culture that we take up residence in, with its laser focus on sexual identity, tolerance, and an individualism that raises its head at every corner, Christians need a robust account of how we got to this point in our Western culture without retreating to our churches nor morphing with the latest trends.   Carl Trueman, professor of religion and theology at Grove City College, brings his keen historical research to bear on this issue in his new book, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self.   Part historical survey and philosophical analysis, Dr. Trueman traces the trajectories of key thinkers such as Rousseau, Freud, and Marx, while also incorporating the insights of Charles Taylor and Phillip Rieff to form a cogent argument as to how we got to this point in our history, both in our expressive individualism and sexual freedom outlooks.   The book is surprisingly insightful and yet demands from the reader the pa

The Conditioned Mind

The Conditioned Mind: Overcoming the Crippling Effects of Sin and Guilt by Michael J. Mannia Counselor and author Michael J. Mannia knows firsthand how the spiraling of sin and guilt can eat away at life.  His new book, The Conditioned Mind, is a look into how believers can overcome the effects of sin and guilt and live in the freedom that we have in Christ.  Through a careful look into the patterns that we develop and the mindsets that we get ingrained in, Michael is able to offer ways through guilt that bring freedom and healing.  I think this is not only a timely but a book that aims toward bringing real healing to its readers. In the first chapter Michael looks at two needs that we have: our need for love and our need for security.  Love isn’t something optional for the human race, but something it needs at its core.  “Additionally, we need to reciprocate love.  We need to feel loved as much as we need to love others (8).”  Love is a two-way street that inv

Passover and Jesus

The Messiah in the Passover , Edited by Darrell Bock and Mitch Glaser Why should Christians celebrate and remember the Passover?   This is a striking question that needs to be understood as well as the historical and theological context of the Passover.   However obscure we sometimes view the Old Testament, there is some significant reasons why we should reach back and study the Passover.   Mitch Glaser in the Introduction states, “When Christians celebrate the Passover, they grow in their understanding of the Old Testament, affirm the Jewishness of the Gospel, deepen our understanding of the Lord’s Supper, and build community with fellow Christians…” (20).   This book is answer to why celebrate the Passover but even more importantly an answer to what the Passover is and what it signifies to us today.   The various contributors of this book, Messiah in the Passover, bring a wealth of ministry experience in relating the Jewishness of both Jesus and the Old Testament to