Skip to main content

True Reason

True Reason Book Cover

True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New Atheism Edited by Tom Gilson and Carson Weitnauer

The onslaught of arguments against God and his existence seems to grow every day.  Yet, we generally hear from only a few atheists in the news, namely the likes of Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, and other notables public figures like Bill Maher.  These virulent men lay claim that their religion is reason and they use reason alone in debating matters of science, religion, and ethics.  But, as many have pointed out, reason is not the only tool in their arsenal.  In this new book called True Reason, edited by Tom Gilson and Carson Weitnauer, the issues surrounding rationality, the Christian faith, and the irrationality of these new atheists come to the foreground.  Gathering a host of wonderful authors, apologists, and teachers, these chapters cut right against the heart of the claim that reason alone is the way of the new atheists.  With stunning insight, sound analysis, and an eye toward the Christian faith, these authors present a brilliant case against the new atheism and its tenents.

Tom Gilson leads off the book with a chapter entitled The Party of Reason?  He comments after reading Richard Dawkins that, “Evolution provides a way for nature to have come about without design, therefore it came about without design.” (16)  Disappointment follows his Tom’s comment due to the lack of evidence or rationality on the part of Dawkins.  Tom goes onto point out that the New Atheists look at reason in two ways, that which can be ascertained by empirical study and to act reasonably.  Yet, there is no hint of reason proper here, the act by which we draw deductive inferences from a premise and then test its viability through observation.  This kind of reasoning is prior to other kinds of logical thinking because it puts at the center the nuts and bolts of sound reasoning and the trajectory of how you get to a certain conclusion from premises.  Tom ends the chapter with an appeal to the Christian faith to show that Christianity is no enemy of reason, nor has it ever been.

One of the best chapters in the book is chapter 4 by Chuck Edwards.  He looks at arguments against God by Richard Dawkins and points out some telling observations.  One, Edwards points out that Dawkins uses two fallacious arguments, poisoning the well and the straw man, to seek to bring down the God of the Old Testament (44).  I would add that in the description of God by Dawkins there is not the slightest hint of a desire to interpret OT passages contextually with reference to the history of Israel or their religion.     Dawkins also fails to consider the positive contributions to society that Christianity has provided, rather he looks for isolated passages in the OT that bolster his straw man argument that God is blood thirsty and capricious. 

Lenny Esposito’s analysis of reason and the new atheism is provocative and very beneficial (ch. 7).  He indicates that we can’t know whether a belief is true or false if our ‘reasoning ability is purely an internal product of biochemical development.’ (104)  We have to get beyond the senses to figure out the truth of the matter.  The New Atheist claim that naturalism is the most reasonable option and true to reason is faulty because it fails to understand that naturalism is a belief itself.  The argument that Christianity provides an outside source of truth is hard to swallow for the New Atheists because this is outside the material and empirical data, or so they say.  Lenny carefully exposes the circular reasoning and unreasonableness of their propositions.

I think anyone wanting to see the New Atheism and all its foibles would do well to read this book.

Thanks to Kregel Publications and General Editor Carson Weitnauer for the copy of this book in exchange for review.


Popular posts from this blog

My Favorite Color is Blue. Sometimes.: A Journey Through Loss with Art and Color

My Favorite Color is Blue. Sometimes by Roger Hutchison

Taking a look at the digital copy of this book allowed me to look at the striking art inside the book, and its connection to the words of the page that were focusing on loss.  Looking at the physical copy of the book even brings to life more the staggering similarity that the words and pain have together on the page.  The focus here is how certain colors express the sentiments of those who have lost a loved one.  I did not think that I would relate too well to this book until two days ago, as we lost our little boy, who was only 17 weeks old.  The pain is palpable and yet the pages of this book give me good reason to think of my son with a sense of pride and hope.

Roger writes, "You are a shooting star. Your light trails across the heavens.  I blinked and you were gone."  We were full of anticipation at the first and second ultrasounds, and there was the picture of our little boy Jackson, his developing face and little …

The Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South

Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose by Flannery O’Connor
A profound simplicity of thought, a penetrating vision of what it means to be human, Flannery O’Connor embodies the spirit of bringing fictional stories to life.  Others might call her fiction ‘grotesque’ in a rather unflattering manner, but O’Connor was not content to live up to their criticisms.  In this short book of collected essay and lectures, Mystery and Manners, editors and friends of Flannery, Robert and Sally Fitzgerald have given us a glimpse into the vision of her faith, style and life as a writer.   A lifelong Catholic, Flannery O’Connor sought to wed together the moral integrity of her faith with the character of her craft in writing.  Specifically, fiction for her was an exploration in imitation.
In a rather illuminating statement in the chapter entitled, “A Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South, “ O’Connor writes,
“I am specifically concerned with fiction because that is what I write.  There is a certain em…