Skip to main content

The Rich Young Ruler, Matthew 19, and the History of Interpretation






The Rich Young Ruler: Matthew 19 and the History of Interpretation

The story of the young rich ruler has puzzled many people for generations.  Not least is the question of wealth, money, and possessions, what does Jesus mean by commanding the young ruler to sell all his possessions and give to the poor?  None of us would counter that giving to the poor and giving up some of our earthly possessions is a bad thing.  Yet, the point revolves around “all.”  Is this story a command for both the rich young ruler and us to give up all to follow Jesus or is there another way of seeing it?  The history of interpretation of this passage is quite interesting, Frederick Dale Bruner writes,

“The History of Interpretation of the Rich Young Ruler is fascinatingly laid out in Luz (Matthew 21-28: A Commentary, Hermeneia, Vol III pp. 131-136, and can be roughly summarized like this:
(
(a) The early church saw Jesus addressing all and took the text literally; rather, early on, however, as we see in the third century Clement of Alexandria above, an “attitude ethic” began to intrude
(Jesus wants to rid us of the attitude of covetousness, not of actual possessions)
(b)   In the post-Constantinian and early medieval periods Jesus was understood as giving counsel to some(the religious), not commands to all
(c)    Then in the late medieval period the allegorical interpretation entered, most perniciously when the Rich Man was interpreted allegorically as a representative of the Jews
(d)   In Reformation interpretation the rich man was explained as an allegory (!) or type, too – namely of the “works-righteous” person, and so our text was used to convict people spiritually, not change them economically.  Luther inverted the text so entirely that now it does not mean divestment, it means (in Wesley’s phrase) “earn all you can, save all you can, give all you can.” Luz protests, “One cannot more thoroughly misunderstand the Command of Poverty in the text.”
(e)    Post-Reformation and modern interpretation saw our text as thoroughly particular, for only certain people or special cases, and not for all disciples.


Luz comments, “We Protestants must learn anew how and why, for Jesus and original Christianity, there was clearly a fundamental tension between the kingdom of God and wealth. We must learn anew that dealing with money is a burning center of faith… The obedience of disciples must profoundly alter our dealing with our own money, because money rules the world and discipleship to Jesus is a protest of love against this government.”

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Saving Casper

Saving Casper: A Christian and an Atheist Talk about Why We Need to Change the Conversion Conversation by Jim Henderson and Matt Casper http://www.amazon.com/Saving-Casper-Christian-Conversion-Conversation/dp/1414364881 Many readers will quickly know the authors of this book from their previous release Jim and Casper Go to Church.  Jim and Matt’s new book entitled Saving Casper focuses on the way we talk about conversion in the church and the devastating ways we have pushed away atheists and other non-believers by our posture.  Both Jim and Matt traversed the national landscape, meeting in churches and asking hard questions about faith, conversion, and life. The basic premise of the book and travel is laid out here in their words, “Part of what Casper and I are trying to achieve when we speak to a group of Christians is to help people move a little bit on their “judgment meter.”  This capacity, while intellectually and often theologically uncomfortable,...
Post a Comment
Read more

Essential Christian Doctrine

  Essential Christian Doctrine , General Editor John MacArthur Pastor John MacArthur has for years been teaching the Word of God in both pulpit ministry, books, and conferences with an aim to displaying God’s revelation to his listeners in a winsome and foundational manner.  This new book, Essential Christian Doctrine takes an entire life of teaching and preaching and encapsulates the main contours of the Christian faith for its readers.  John in a systematic way highlights the most necessary teachings from Scripture including God’s Word, the Trinity, while also including sections on Man and the Future. One of the most helpful ways the authors bring to light biblical truth and theology is the way in which they group together particular themes.  In the section on the Holy Spirit, instead of a complex discussion of personhood, word pictures of the Holy Spirit are introduced in a discernible and profitable manner.  The metaphors for the Holy Spirit include fir...
Post a Comment
Read more

Wisdom for All

Interpreting the Wisdom Books: An Exegetical Handbook by Edward Custis Among the many wonderful books on the OT wisdom literature, this fine new book helps the reader interpret, exegete, and apply God’s Word to his people in succinct and helpful way.  The book is laid out nicely with bolded words that emphasize necessary themes in the study of the wisdom books and short chapters that get to the point of the biblical books.  This series of exegetical handbooks is a great treasure for students and pastors because it synthesizes much of the academic work on a biblical book into digestable portions helpful  for preaching and teaching. The opening chapter on the wisdom books brings out a helpful grid for understanding wisdom literature.  Custis writes, “Biblical wisdom, in contrast to Israel’s neighbors, reflects “Yahwistic theology” through its regular use of terms like “fear of the Lord,” its affirmation of God’s providence, and its recognition th...
Post a Comment
Read more